- Axiological: what makes writing good?
This is a very subjective
question, but must be answered because how can we grade if we do not have a
rubric? There are several aspects that make a piece of writing inherently successful.
First of all, is there a point made and is that point backed up with supporting
details? Does the writing include an introduction and a conclusion? Of course,
this is the standard for a coherent essay, but it would not necessarily apply
to a creative work in the same way. This brings us to genre. Does the writing
meet the requirements of the assignment and address the intended audience and
fit the context of the situation? As we move toward teaching for transfer and
interdisciplinary classrooms, genre plays a greater role in determining if
writing is effective. A student who understands the rhetorical situation of
their writing and has embraced a personal voice will do well in most
classrooms.
- Process: how do texts come into existence?
There are many things to
consider in the creation of a text (see above regarding genre and context) and
although we often teach or have learned there is a specific regimen to follow
in the creation of a text, most writers develop their own process which may in
turn change with the type of writing being done. When it comes to process, making
students aware of process – as we did with our literacy narratives – can prove enlightening
and encouraging multiple ways of completing the same tasks can also prove
beneficial. In reviewing my own writing process, I realized some of the things
that are working for me and some of the things which are not. I think exploring
this in the classroom could be very helpful for students and encourage them to notice
that even if they are a one-draft-and-done type of writing, there is more that
happens in that one draft than they may recognize.
- Pedagogy: how does one teach hs/college students effectively?
One of the keys is
getting and keeping student engagement, through using topics that speak to
students, finding ways to relate to them and encouraging the development of
individuality and the creation of voice. Also, creating a positive environment fosters
growth and development rather than a focus on correction and judgment.
Workshopping papers in class and offering student conferences can help build a
more comfortable rapport and I believe using a check, check minus, check plus
grading system throughout the semester followed by a cumulative portfolio can
help create a focus on growth and development as well.
- Epistemological: how do you know that?
Many of our readings have touched on these issues, but I
also know these things from my own experiences both as a student and as a teacher.
I will pull quotes from our assigned readings to specifically back up my claims,
but for the time being, let it suffice that I know I have notated some of these
already but have neither the time nor the energy at nearly 11 p.m. on the night this
is due when I still haven’t eaten dinner and I have to work at midnight.
No comments:
Post a Comment